| Matchup | Predicted | Actual | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gardner Webb @ High Point | High Point (High Point -23.79) | High Point +22.0 | Correct |
| Bellarmine @ Central Arkansas | Central Arkansas (Central Arkansas -11.4) | Central Arkansas +13.0 | Correct |
| Drake @ Belmont | Belmont (Belmont -16.2) | Drake +21.0 | Miss |
| Northeastern @ North Carolina A&T | North Carolina A&T (North Carolina A&T -11.72) | Northeastern +16.0 | Miss |
| Charleston Southern @ Winthrop | Winthrop (Winthrop -9.63) | Winthrop +5.0 | Correct |
| Florida Gulf Coast @ Lipscomb | Lipscomb (Lipscomb -4.7) | Florida Gulf Coast +24.0 | Miss |
| Illinois-Chicago @ Murray St. | Murray St. (Murray St. -1.61) | Illinois-Chicago +13.0 | Miss |
| Stetson @ Austin Peay | Austin Peay (Austin Peay -2.51) | Austin Peay +9.0 | Correct |
| Citadel @ Chattanooga | Citadel (Citadel -0.28) | Citadel +3.0 | Correct |
| Southern Miss @ Texas St. | Texas St. (Texas St. -1.61) | Southern Miss +4.0 | Miss |
| Sacred Heart @ Merrimack | Merrimack (Merrimack -13.54) | Merrimack +22.0 | Correct |
| Longwood @ NC Asheville | NC Asheville (NC Asheville -5.68) | NC Asheville +3.0 | Correct |
| Northern Illinois @ Akron | Akron (Akron -23.18) | Akron +39.0 | Correct |
| Bowling Green @ Eastern Michigan | Eastern Michigan (Eastern Michigan -4.05) | Bowling Green +8.0 | Miss |
| Nebraska Omaha @ South Dakota | South Dakota (South Dakota -1.75) | Nebraska Omaha +14.0 | Miss |
| Pennsylvania @ Brown | Pennsylvania (Pennsylvania -12.06) | Pennsylvania +21.0 | Correct |
| Valparaiso @ Bradley | Bradley (Bradley -2.27) | Bradley +6.0 | Correct |
| VA Commonwealth @ Dayton | VA Commonwealth (VA Commonwealth -0.0) | VA Commonwealth +6.0 | Correct |
| Western Michigan @ Kent St. | Kent St. (Kent St. -11.03) | Kent St. +8.0 | Correct |
| Buffalo @ Toledo | Toledo (Toledo -3.6) | Toledo +20.0 | Correct |
| Columbia @ Harvard | Harvard (Harvard -8.69) | Harvard +10.0 | Correct |
| Central Michigan @ Ball St. | Central Michigan (Central Michigan -3.29) | Ball St. +16.0 | Miss |
| VMI @ NC Greensboro | NC Greensboro (NC Greensboro -15.2) | NC Greensboro +14.0 | Correct |
| West Georgia @ Queens University | Queens University (Queens University -2.47) | Queens University +8.0 | Correct |
| Tennessee-Martin @ Tennessee St. | Tennessee St. (Tennessee St. -5.19) | Tennessee St. +13.0 | Correct |
| Central Florida @ West Virginia | Central Florida (Central Florida -4.7) | West Virginia +15.0 | Miss |
| Fairfield @ St. Peter's | St. Peter's (St. Peter's -2.95) | Fairfield +19.0 | Miss |
| Presbyterian @ Radford | Radford (Radford -7.36) | Presbyterian +6.0 | Miss |
| Georgia Southern @ South Alabama | South Alabama (South Alabama -7.55) | Georgia Southern +9.0 | Miss |
| Portland @ Washington St. | Washington St. (Washington St. -1.13) | Portland +6.0 | Miss |
| Miami-Ohio @ Ohio | Miami-Ohio (Miami-Ohio -12.82) | Miami-Ohio +2.0 | Correct |
| St. John's @ Seton Hall | St. John's (St. John's -6.76) | St. John's +7.0 | Correct |
| Denver @ North Dakota | Denver (Denver -0.18) | North Dakota +16.0 | Miss |
| Northern Iowa @ Illinois St. | Northern Iowa (Northern Iowa -0.48) | Northern Iowa +22.0 | Correct |
| UNLV @ San Diego St. | San Diego St. (San Diego St. -7.11) | San Diego St. +3.0 | Correct |
| SE Missouri St. @ Morehead St. | SE Missouri St. (SE Missouri St. -1.07) | Morehead St. +5.0 | Miss |
| San Diego @ Seattle | Seattle (Seattle -10.18) | Seattle +2.0 | Correct |
Spread indicates the favorite using betting notation (favorite with minus points, opponent with the corresponding plus).