| Matchup | Predicted | Actual | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manhattan @ Niagara | Niagara (Niagara -7.95) | Manhattan +7.0 | Miss |
| George Mason @ George Washington | George Mason (George Mason -9.16) | George Washington +19.0 | Miss |
| Cornell @ Princeton | Princeton (Princeton -8.07) | Cornell +24.0 | Miss |
| St. Peter's @ Sacred Heart | St. Peter's (St. Peter's -8.59) | Sacred Heart +7.0 | Miss |
| Yale @ Dartmouth | Yale (Yale -13.29) | Yale +13.0 | Correct |
| Quinnipiac @ Siena | Siena (Siena -3.47) | Quinnipiac +12.0 | Miss |
| Mount St. Marys @ Rider | Mount St. Marys (Mount St. Marys -6.49) | Mount St. Marys +10.0 | Correct |
| Iona @ Canisius | Iona (Iona -6.24) | Iona +6.0 | Correct |
| Brown @ Harvard | Harvard (Harvard -13.09) | Harvard +3.0 | Correct |
| Columbia @ Pennsylvania | Pennsylvania (Pennsylvania -8.65) | Pennsylvania +9.0 | Correct |
| Michigan St. @ Wisconsin | Michigan St. (Michigan St. -3.59) | Wisconsin +21.0 | Miss |
| Saint Louis @ Loyola-Chicago | Saint Louis (Saint Louis -21.51) | Saint Louis +27.0 | Correct |
| Massachusetts @ Akron | Akron (Akron -10.62) | Akron +7.0 | Correct |
| Ohio @ Miami-Ohio | Miami-Ohio (Miami-Ohio -17.1) | Miami-Ohio +16.0 | Correct |
| UNLV @ Boise St. | Boise St. (Boise St. -6.22) | UNLV +3.0 | Miss |
| Hampton @ North Carolina A&T | Hampton (Hampton -1.12) | North Carolina A&T +1.0 | Miss |
Spread indicates the favorite using betting notation (favorite with minus points, opponent with the corresponding plus).