| Matchup | Predicted | Actual | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bryant @ Brown | Bryant (Bryant -3.51) | Brown +19.0 | Miss |
| Gonzaga @ Kentucky | Gonzaga (Gonzaga -8.39) | Gonzaga +35.0 | Correct |
| NJIT @ High Point | High Point (High Point -29.7) | High Point +17.0 | Correct |
| South Alabama @ East Tennessee St. | South Alabama (South Alabama -2.94) | East Tennessee St. +26.0 | Miss |
| Samford @ VA Commonwealth | VA Commonwealth (VA Commonwealth -13.73) | VA Commonwealth +26.0 | Correct |
| Quinnipiac @ Iona | Iona (Iona -6.61) | Quinnipiac +21.0 | Miss |
| South Carolina St. @ Bethune Cookman | Bethune Cookman (Bethune Cookman -13.6) | Bethune Cookman +21.0 | Correct |
| Niagara @ Siena | Siena (Siena -17.48) | Siena +29.0 | Correct |
| Canisius @ St. Peter's | Canisius (Canisius -5.98) | St. Peter's +12.0 | Miss |
| Mount St. Marys @ Marist | Marist (Marist -18.98) | Marist +8.0 | Correct |
| Fairfield @ Manhattan | Fairfield (Fairfield -9.13) | Manhattan +4.0 | Miss |
| Mercyhurst @ Lafayette | Mercyhurst (Mercyhurst -7.21) | Lafayette +8.0 | Miss |
| Christendom Crusaders @ VMI | Christendom Crusaders (Christendom Crusaders -2.65) | VMI +53.0 | Miss |
| UAB @ Drake | Drake (Drake -3.9) | UAB +5.0 | Miss |
| Cincinnati @ Xavier | Xavier (Xavier -7.05) | Xavier +5.0 | Correct |
| East Texas A&M @ Connecticut | Connecticut (Connecticut -25.08) | Connecticut +24.0 | Correct |
| Cleary University Cougars @ Eastern Michigan | Eastern Michigan (Eastern Michigan -48.84) | Eastern Michigan +38.0 | Correct |
| Northwestern St. @ McNeese St. | McNeese St. (McNeese St. -21.29) | McNeese St. +38.0 | Correct |
| Notre Dame @ TCU | Notre Dame (Notre Dame -0.03) | Notre Dame +2.0 | Correct |
| San Diego @ San Jose St. | San Diego (San Diego -1.59) | San Jose St. +17.0 | Miss |
| Lewis & Clark Pioneers @ Portland | Portland (Portland -17.89) | Portland +17.0 | Correct |
Spread indicates the favorite using betting notation (favorite with minus points, opponent with the corresponding plus).