| Matchup | Predicted | Actual | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Md. Eastern Shore @ Virginia Tech | Virginia Tech (Virginia Tech -24.6) | Virginia Tech +29.0 | Correct |
| Saint Francis Red Flash @ Temple | Temple (Temple -15.11) | Temple +28.0 | Correct |
| Eastern Illinois @ Iowa St. | Iowa St. (Iowa St. -35.39) | Iowa St. +25.0 | Correct |
| Texas Southern @ Minnesota | Minnesota (Minnesota -9.14) | Minnesota +36.0 | Correct |
| Buffalo @ East Carolina | Buffalo (Buffalo -15.36) | East Carolina +3.0 | Miss |
| Indiana St. @ Wisconsin-Milwaukee | Indiana St. (Indiana St. -7.24) | Indiana St. +2.0 | Correct |
| Ball St. @ Campbell | Campbell (Campbell -4.03) | Campbell +5.0 | Correct |
| Monmouth @ Fairfield | Fairfield (Fairfield -3.36) | Fairfield +8.0 | Correct |
| High Point @ Appalachian St. | High Point (High Point -14.23) | Appalachian St. +8.0 | Miss |
| Thiel Tomcats @ Youngstown St. | Youngstown St. (Youngstown St. -17.87) | Youngstown St. +51.0 | Correct |
| Bethune Cookman @ Missouri | Missouri (Missouri -21.08) | Missouri +22.0 | Correct |
| Oakland City Mighty Oaks @ Cleveland St. | Cleveland St. (Cleveland St. -21.33) | Cleveland St. +44.0 | Correct |
| Eureka Red Devils @ SIU Edwardsville | SIU Edwardsville (SIU Edwardsville -18.01) | SIU Edwardsville +43.0 | Correct |
| North Central College Cardinals @ Bradley | Bradley (Bradley -20.62) | Bradley +33.0 | Correct |
| Merrimack @ Vermont | Vermont (Vermont -2.56) | Vermont +7.0 | Correct |
| Coppin St. @ Radford | Radford (Radford -19.13) | Radford +30.0 | Correct |
| Western Michigan @ Iowa | Iowa (Iowa -13.72) | Iowa +40.0 | Correct |
| Northern New Mexico Coll. @ Colorado St. | Colorado St. (Colorado St. -25.9) | Colorado St. +50.0 | Correct |
| St. Xavier (IL) Cougars @ SE Missouri St. | SE Missouri St. (SE Missouri St. -33.09) | SE Missouri St. +23.0 | Correct |
| Troy St. @ UAB | UAB (UAB -12.43) | Troy St. +1.0 | Miss |
| Florida Gulf Coast @ New Mexico | New Mexico (New Mexico -10.03) | New Mexico +16.0 | Correct |
| NC Charlotte @ Charleston | NC Charlotte (NC Charlotte -1.66) | Charleston +7.0 | Miss |
| Chicago St. @ Loyola-Chicago | Loyola-Chicago (Loyola-Chicago -5.29) | Chicago St. +9.0 | Miss |
| Evergreen State Geoducks @ Idaho | Idaho (Idaho -10.93) | Idaho +54.0 | Correct |
| Kent St. @ Portland | Kent St. (Kent St. -7.99) | Portland +10.0 | Miss |
| Queens University @ Wake Forest | Wake Forest (Wake Forest -18.42) | Wake Forest +38.0 | Correct |
| Detroit @ IPFW | Detroit (Detroit -3.29) | IPFW +4.0 | Miss |
| North Texas @ South Alabama | South Alabama (South Alabama -2.85) | North Texas +1.0 | Miss |
| Champion Christian Tigers @ Tennessee-Martin | Tennessee-Martin (Tennessee-Martin -53.38) | Tennessee-Martin +44.0 | Correct |
| St. Mary's @ Boise St. | St. Mary's (St. Mary's -5.28) | Boise St. +1.0 | Miss |
| Jacksonville @ Texas A&M | Texas A&M (Texas A&M -19.15) | Texas A&M +37.0 | Correct |
| Washington St. @ USC | USC (USC -22.26) | USC +7.0 | Correct |
Spread indicates the favorite using betting notation (favorite with minus points, opponent with the corresponding plus).