| Matchup | Predicted | Actual | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Norfolk St. @ Baylor | Baylor (Baylor -18.45) | Baylor +30.0 | Correct |
| Albany-NY @ Yale | Yale (Yale -22.98) | Yale +11.0 | Correct |
| Merrimack @ Princeton | Merrimack (Merrimack -7.96) | Merrimack +3.0 | Correct |
| Miami-Ohio @ NC Asheville | Miami-Ohio (Miami-Ohio -8.66) | Miami-Ohio +3.0 | Correct |
| Fisher College Eagles @ Umass Lowell | Umass Lowell (Umass Lowell -4.99) | Umass Lowell +49.0 | Correct |
| Minnesota @ Purdue | Purdue (Purdue -21.69) | Purdue +28.0 | Correct |
| New Haven Chargers @ NJIT | New Haven Chargers (New Haven Chargers -7.16) | NJIT +6.0 | Miss |
| Charleston @ South Florida | South Florida (South Florida -9.76) | South Florida +6.0 | Correct |
| Saint Leo Monarchs @ Florida Atlantic | Florida Atlantic (Florida Atlantic -22.74) | Florida Atlantic +57.0 | Correct |
| Western Kentucky @ Marshall | Western Kentucky (Western Kentucky -1.98) | Marshall +16.0 | Miss |
| New Mexico @ VA Commonwealth | VA Commonwealth (VA Commonwealth -0.4) | New Mexico +3.0 | Miss |
| Maine @ Boston | Boston (Boston -14.09) | Maine +10.0 | Miss |
| Old Westbury Panthers @ Hofstra | Hofstra (Hofstra -22.44) | Hofstra +69.0 | Correct |
| Idaho @ Notre Dame | Notre Dame (Notre Dame -12.68) | Notre Dame +15.0 | Correct |
| Liberty @ North Carolina St. | North Carolina St. (North Carolina St. -9.49) | North Carolina St. +40.0 | Correct |
| Massachusetts @ Boston College | Massachusetts (Massachusetts -1.36) | Massachusetts +2.0 | Correct |
| Colgate @ St. Bonaventure | St. Bonaventure (St. Bonaventure -14.78) | St. Bonaventure +8.0 | Correct |
| Delaware @ George Washington | George Washington (George Washington -29.48) | Delaware +12.0 | Miss |
| Fairleigh Dickinson @ Fordham | Fordham (Fordham -12.79) | Fordham +21.0 | Correct |
| Bryant @ Iona | Iona (Iona -18.33) | Iona +6.0 | Correct |
| Tougaloo Bulldogs @ Tulane | Tulane (Tulane -30.46) | Tulane +12.0 | Correct |
| College Of Biblical Studies Ambassadors @ Nicholls St. | Nicholls St. (Nicholls St. -52.32) | Nicholls St. +68.0 | Correct |
| Eastern Kentucky @ Eastern Illinois | Eastern Illinois (Eastern Illinois -8.03) | Eastern Kentucky +9.0 | Miss |
| Jackson St. @ Houston | Houston (Houston -32.99) | Houston +42.0 | Correct |
| Crown College Polars @ North Dakota | Crown College Polars (Crown College Polars -5.12) | North Dakota +46.0 | Miss |
| Tennessee-Martin @ Southern Illinois | Tennessee-Martin (Tennessee-Martin -6.75) | Southern Illinois +29.0 | Miss |
| Arkansas Pine Bluff @ Tulsa | Tulsa (Tulsa -29.38) | Tulsa +33.0 | Correct |
| Idaho St. @ Utah Valley | Utah Valley (Utah Valley -5.68) | Utah Valley +4.0 | Correct |
| Eastern Michigan @ IPFW | Eastern Michigan (Eastern Michigan -10.64) | IPFW +15.0 | Miss |
| Weber St. @ Mo Kansas City | Weber St. (Weber St. -9.08) | Weber St. +4.0 | Correct |
| Southern @ Texas St. | Texas St. (Texas St. -12.19) | Texas St. +3.0 | Correct |
| Wisconsin @ Nebraska | Nebraska (Nebraska -10.33) | Nebraska +30.0 | Correct |
| Salish Kootenai Bison @ Montana | Montana (Montana -12.99) | Montana +56.0 | Correct |
| Duquesne @ Boise St. | Boise St. (Boise St. -4.89) | Boise St. +22.0 | Correct |
| Bethesda University Flames @ Cal St. Fullerton | Cal St. Fullerton (Cal St. Fullerton -49.35) | Cal St. Fullerton +50.0 | Correct |
| Lamar @ San Diego St. | San Diego St. (San Diego St. -16.24) | San Diego St. +18.0 | Correct |
| Fresno St. @ CS Northridge | Fresno St. (Fresno St. -3.45) | CS Northridge +2.0 | Miss |
| Hawai'i Hilo Vulcans @ Hawaii | Hawaii (Hawaii -28.13) | Hawaii +52.0 | Correct |
Spread indicates the favorite using betting notation (favorite with minus points, opponent with the corresponding plus).