| Matchup | Predicted | Actual | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arkansas Baptist Buffaloes @ Louisiana-Monroe | Louisiana-Monroe (Louisiana-Monroe -24.7) | Louisiana-Monroe +10.0 | Correct |
| Buffalo @ MD Baltimore Co | Buffalo (Buffalo -11.57) | Buffalo +4.0 | Correct |
| Loyola-Maryland @ VMI | Loyola-Maryland (Loyola-Maryland -6.27) | VMI +16.0 | Miss |
| Regis Pride @ Holy Cross | Holy Cross (Holy Cross -8.92) | Holy Cross +22.0 | Correct |
| Bob Jones Bruins @ Furman | Furman (Furman -54.5) | Furman +48.0 | Correct |
| Toccoa Falls Eagles @ Winthrop | Winthrop (Winthrop -43.31) | Winthrop +49.0 | Correct |
| Villanova @ Michigan | Michigan (Michigan -11.43) | Michigan +28.0 | Correct |
| Clemson @ BYU | BYU (BYU -15.35) | BYU +3.0 | Correct |
| Oakwood Ambassadors @ Chattanooga | Chattanooga (Chattanooga -28.65) | Chattanooga +57.0 | Correct |
| NC Central @ Kentucky | Kentucky (Kentucky -16.22) | Kentucky +36.0 | Correct |
| Georgian Court Lions @ Temple | Temple (Temple -13.07) | Temple +46.0 | Correct |
| Southern Wesleyan Warriors @ Citadel | Southern Wesleyan Warriors (Southern Wesleyan Warriors -14.74) | Citadel +25.0 | Miss |
| North Carolina A&T @ Howard | North Carolina A&T (North Carolina A&T -1.76) | Howard +4.0 | Miss |
| Brescia Bearcats @ Northern Kentucky | Northern Kentucky (Northern Kentucky -26.7) | Northern Kentucky +39.0 | Correct |
| Md. Eastern Shore @ Virginia | Virginia (Virginia -27.19) | Virginia +24.0 | Correct |
| Culver-Stockton Wildcats @ Lindenwood | Lindenwood (Lindenwood -18.13) | Lindenwood +66.0 | Correct |
| South Dakota St. @ Ball St. | South Dakota St. (South Dakota St. -4.25) | South Dakota St. +4.0 | Correct |
| Arkansas-Little Rock @ West Virginia | West Virginia (West Virginia -20.58) | West Virginia +32.0 | Correct |
| Columbia @ Stony Brook | Columbia (Columbia -11.12) | Stony Brook +4.0 | Miss |
| McNeese St. @ Rhode Island | Rhode Island (Rhode Island -6.49) | McNeese St. +2.0 | Miss |
| Coppin St. @ St. Joseph's PA | St. Joseph's PA (St. Joseph's PA -22.62) | St. Joseph's PA +22.0 | Correct |
| Bucknell @ Rider | Rider (Rider -4.94) | Bucknell +13.0 | Miss |
| Illinois @ Ohio St. | Illinois (Illinois -1.12) | Illinois +8.0 | Correct |
| Brown @ Providence | Providence (Providence -19.31) | Providence +7.0 | Correct |
| Morgan St. @ DePaul | DePaul (DePaul -18.41) | DePaul +43.0 | Correct |
| Doane Tigers @ Nebraska Omaha | Nebraska Omaha (Nebraska Omaha -9.43) | Nebraska Omaha +9.0 | Correct |
| Penn St. @ Indiana | Penn St. (Penn St. -3.24) | Indiana +41.0 | Miss |
| South Dakota @ Wyoming | Wyoming (Wyoming -15.31) | Wyoming +27.0 | Correct |
| Florida @ Connecticut | Connecticut (Connecticut -9.85) | Connecticut +4.0 | Correct |
| Colorado Christian Cougars @ Denver | Colorado Christian Cougars (Colorado Christian Cougars -15.47) | Denver +36.0 | Miss |
| USC @ San Diego | USC (USC -14.37) | USC +13.0 | Correct |
| Dartmouth @ Colorado St. | Colorado St. (Colorado St. -21.67) | Colorado St. +21.0 | Correct |
| Northern Arizona @ Arizona St. | Arizona St. (Arizona St. -14.08) | Arizona St. +25.0 | Correct |
| Dominican (CA) Penguins @ California | California (California -36.44) | California +22.0 | Correct |
| Long Beach St. @ San Jose St. | San Jose St. (San Jose St. -10.99) | San Jose St. +6.0 | Correct |
Spread indicates the favorite using betting notation (favorite with minus points, opponent with the corresponding plus).