| Matchup | Predicted | Actual | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stetson @ North Alabama | North Alabama (North Alabama -5.95) | Stetson +3.0 | Miss |
| Georgia Southern @ Coastal Carolina | Georgia Southern (Georgia Southern -3.57) | Georgia Southern +1.0 | Correct |
| Samford @ VMI | Samford (Samford -7.57) | Samford +20.0 | Correct |
| Oakland @ Youngstown St. | Youngstown St. (Youngstown St. -2.69) | Oakland +2.0 | Miss |
| Elms College Blazers @ Dartmouth | Dartmouth (Dartmouth -64.25) | Dartmouth +64.0 | Correct |
| Florida Gulf Coast @ Central Arkansas | Florida Gulf Coast (Florida Gulf Coast -6.59) | Central Arkansas +2.0 | Miss |
| Wisconsin-Green Bay @ IPFW | Wisconsin-Green Bay (Wisconsin-Green Bay -4.5) | Wisconsin-Green Bay +18.0 | Correct |
| Jacksonville @ Lipscomb | Lipscomb (Lipscomb -18.6) | Lipscomb +19.0 | Correct |
| IUPUI @ Northern Kentucky | Northern Kentucky (Northern Kentucky -18.22) | Northern Kentucky +9.0 | Correct |
| Oral Roberts @ North Dakota | North Dakota (North Dakota -3.17) | North Dakota +11.0 | Correct |
| Wisconsin-Milwaukee @ Wright St. | Wright St. (Wright St. -4.7) | Wright St. +6.0 | Correct |
| California Baptist @ Texas Arlington | California Baptist (California Baptist -7.8) | Texas Arlington +12.0 | Miss |
| Valparaiso @ Southern Illinois | Valparaiso (Valparaiso -1.23) | Southern Illinois +5.0 | Miss |
| Evansville @ Illinois St. | Illinois St. (Illinois St. -17.83) | Illinois St. +26.0 | Correct |
| Chattanooga @ NC Greensboro | NC Greensboro (NC Greensboro -1.98) | NC Greensboro +5.0 | Correct |
| Portland St. @ Weber St. | Portland St. (Portland St. -4.45) | Portland St. +5.0 | Correct |
| Morehead St. @ Lindenwood | Lindenwood (Lindenwood -12.63) | Lindenwood +13.0 | Correct |
| Western Illinois @ Tennessee-Martin | Tennessee-Martin (Tennessee-Martin -13.23) | Tennessee-Martin +7.0 | Correct |
| Southern Indiana @ SIU Edwardsville | SIU Edwardsville (SIU Edwardsville -8.6) | SIU Edwardsville +4.0 | Correct |
| CS Northridge @ UC Davis | UC Davis (UC Davis -6.59) | UC Davis +9.0 | Correct |
| UC Irvine @ CS Bakersfield | UC Irvine (UC Irvine -5.62) | UC Irvine +4.0 | Correct |
| Southern Miss @ Louisiana-Monroe | Southern Miss (Southern Miss -11.06) | Southern Miss +14.0 | Correct |
| Nebraska Omaha @ South Dakota St. | Nebraska Omaha (Nebraska Omaha -1.12) | South Dakota St. +15.0 | Miss |
| Northern Arizona @ Montana | Northern Arizona (Northern Arizona -4.09) | Montana +14.0 | Miss |
| Tennessee Tech @ Arkansas-Little Rock | Arkansas-Little Rock (Arkansas-Little Rock -0.31) | Arkansas-Little Rock +19.0 | Correct |
| Bradley @ Belmont | Belmont (Belmont -8.74) | Belmont +10.0 | Correct |
| Eastern Kentucky @ Queens University | Queens University (Queens University -9.15) | Queens University +2.0 | Correct |
| Bellarmine @ West Georgia | West Georgia (West Georgia -6.74) | West Georgia +2.0 | Correct |
| Utah Valley @ Tarleton St. | Tarleton St. (Tarleton St. -1.55) | Utah Valley +6.0 | Miss |
| Utah Tech @ Abilene Christian | Abilene Christian (Abilene Christian -10.83) | Utah Tech +15.0 | Miss |
| Hawaii @ Cal Riverside | Hawaii (Hawaii -6.88) | Hawaii +43.0 | Correct |
| Indiana St. @ Northern Iowa | Northern Iowa (Northern Iowa -11.67) | Northern Iowa +9.0 | Correct |
| North Florida @ Austin Peay | Austin Peay (Austin Peay -11.86) | Austin Peay +19.0 | Correct |
| Eastern Illinois @ SE Missouri St. | SE Missouri St. (SE Missouri St. -0.95) | SE Missouri St. +9.0 | Correct |
| Murray St. @ Illinois-Chicago | Murray St. (Murray St. -12.73) | Murray St. +4.0 | Correct |
| Northern Colorado @ Montana St. | Northern Colorado (Northern Colorado -9.43) | Montana St. +14.0 | Miss |
| CS Sacramento @ Idaho St. | Idaho St. (Idaho St. -13.64) | Idaho St. +13.0 | Correct |
| UC Santa Barbara @ Cal St. Fullerton | UC Santa Barbara (UC Santa Barbara -8.52) | Cal St. Fullerton +11.0 | Miss |
| UC San Diego @ Cal Poly SLO | UC San Diego (UC San Diego -14.78) | Cal Poly SLO +2.0 | Miss |
Spread indicates the favorite using betting notation (favorite with minus points, opponent with the corresponding plus).